How to Perform Successful Website Security Audit: Checklist & Essential Tools

What is website security audit?

A website security audit is a comprehensive process that evaluates and analyzes a website for security vulnerabilities, threats, and risks.

In other words, website security audit is a process of scanning your website to identify loopholes and vulnerabilities.

The reason is simple. Every website owner has to prevent cyberattacks. Conducting regular website security audits ensures the security and integrity.

Website security audit vs. web application security audits

A website security audit goes beyond the application itself to include the hosting environment, server setup, network security, SSL/TLS certificates, and any related services such as content management systems (CMS) and their plug-ins.

This audit assesses server and network setups, assures adherence to security protocols, and checks physical server and data center safety if necessary.

The primary goal is to protect the entire website and infrastructure from various cyberattacks. When conducting a website security audit, it is essential to concentrate on operation aspects, like server setups, domain security, and CMS weaknesses.

A web application security audit, on the other hand, focuses only on making web applications secure.

Web application security scans check the software and application-level aspects. These are elements such as application code for vulnerabilities like SQL injection, XSS, CSRF, issues with authentication and authorization mechanisms, session management, data validation, API security, and the overall logic and business rules of the web application.

The goal is to find and fix vulnerabilities in the web application, to prevent attacks at the application level.

Since we understand the difference, let’s focus today on the website security audit process. In the upcoming article, we will take a closer look at web application security audits.

Why should you conduct web security audits? List of benefits

Web security audits offer many advantages and play a crucial role in maintaining the safety and integrity of online systems.

Some key advantages include:

Identification of vulnerabilities

Audits systematically uncover weaknesses in a website that could be exploited by cyberattackers. This early detection allows for timely remediation before any damage occurs.

Enhanced security

By addressing the website vulnerabilities found during a web security audit, the overall security of the website is significantly improved, reducing the risk of data breaches and cyberattacks.

Compliance with regulations

Regular security audits ensure that websites comply with legal and regulatory requirements related to data protection and privacy, such as GDPR, HIPAA, etc. This compliance is crucial for avoiding legal penalties and maintaining trust.

Protection of sensitive data

Audits help protect sensitive information such as customer data, financial records, and personal information. Maintaining confidentiality and preventing data leakage is where your website security audit can help your customers and users.

Improved user trust and credibility

A secure website or application fosters trust among users and customers. Knowing that a site is regularly audited and secure can enhance its reputation and credibility.

Prevention of financial loss

Security breaches often result in significant financial loss due to data theft, legal penalties, or business interruption. By aligning with the organization’s security policies, audits help prevent such incidents and their potential consequences, and protect the financial health of the organization.

Enhanced performance and uptime

Addressing security issues can also improve the performance and reliability of a website or application, ensuring better uptime and user experience.

Website security audit checklist

Before beginning a website security audit, it’s important to identify the specific elements of the site that need to be examined.

To ensure a thorough examination, the following website items should be included in a web audit checklist:

1. Core website framework

The audit begins with a detailed examination of the website’s basic structure and code base.

This includes a review of the platform or content management system (CMS) used to build the site, such as WordPress or Joomla.

The focus is on identifying any inherent vulnerabilities in the framework, including insecure coding practices, use of outdated libraries, or specific vulnerabilities associated with the chosen platform.

2. Web server configuration and software

This step involves a thorough assessment of the hosting server’s configuration and the software running on it.

It’s important to make sure that all software, including the operating system, web server (such as Apache or Nginx), and database server are up to date with the latest security patches.

The configuration should be checked for vulnerabilities such as directory traversal and to ensure that appropriate security modules are enabled.

3. Web extensions and plugins

The audit also includes an inspection of any additional functionality integrated into the site via plugins or extensions.

This includes checking for outdated or unmaintained plugins that may contain security vulnerabilities.

Each plugin or extension should be evaluated for necessity, and those that pose security risks should be removed or replaced.

4. SSL/TLS Security

The integrity and implementation of SSL/TLS protocols on the website are verified to ensure secure data transmission between the user’s browser and the website.

This includes verifying the validity and proper installation of SSL certificates and ensuring that they are up to date.

5. Data management and encryption

This part of the audit focuses on how the website manages, stores, and transmits data.

It focuses on the encryption methods used to protect sensitive information, such as user credentials and payment information.

It also includes a review of database security practices, including encryption of data at rest and secure data transfer methods.

6. Third-party integrations

Any external services or APIs integrated with the site are evaluated for potential vulnerabilities they may introduce.

This step includes evaluating the security measures of these third-party services and ensuring that any data sharing or permissions granted to them comply with established security standards.

7. Information processing and handling

The final step in this part of the audit is to review how sensitive information is processed and handled on the website.

This includes ensuring compliance with security standards and regulations, such as GDPR for personal data, and examining the website’s practices for collecting, storing, accessing, and sharing information both internally and with third parties.

8. Vulnerability scanning

This is the process of using automated tools to scan a Website for known security vulnerabilities. These tools perform scans to detect issues such as SQL injection, cross-site scripting (XSS), insecure server configurations, outdated software components, and other common vulnerabilities.

9. Penetration testing

Penetration testing, also called pen testing, involves simulating cyberattacks by security professionals to understand how a hacker might exploit vulnerabilities.

These pen testers use the same techniques as real attackers, but do so ethically and legally to assess security vulnerabilities.

The primary goal is to identify vulnerabilities before actual attackers do. This includes testing for issues such as SQL injection, cross-site scripting (XSS), cross-site request forgery (CSRF), insecure server configurations, and authentication weaknesses.

Pen testers also evaluate the effectiveness of existing security policies and procedures. They test how well these policies hold up against attempted breaches.

Penetration testing can be manual or automated.

10. Code review

A web security audit involves systematic examination of the website’s source code to identify security vulnerabilities, coding errors, or deviations from best coding practices.

The code review process is essential for ensuring the security and reliability of a website.

11. Site settings and user permissions

Audit user accounts and permissions, as well as website settings, should be on your website security checklist, too.

It is crucial to protect against unauthorized access and potential security breaches. This review ensures compliance with the principle of least privilege, where users are granted only the access required for their roles, thereby reducing the risk of data breaches and insider threats.

Regular auditing of user accounts helps identify and remediate redundant or obsolete accounts that could otherwise become security liabilities.

In addition, auditing website settings is essential for detecting configuration errors that could lead to vulnerabilities, improving overall security, and maintaining website integrity.

12. Performance and reliability testing

Performance and reliability testing is an important aspect of maintaining a website, focusing on its capacity to handle high traffic and maintain website performance under various conditions.

Although not a direct part of security audits, this testing is crucial for assessing a site’s resilience against Denial of Service (DoS) attacks. By identifying how much load a website can handle before performance degradation, it helps in pinpointing vulnerabilities and planning for capacity enhancements.

This testing indirectly enhances security by preparing the site to handle potential traffic spikes and ensuring consistent performance and reliability, which are key to a positive user experience and overall site stability.

13. Reporting and remediation

After the audit, a detailed report should be prepared highlighting the vulnerabilities found, their severity, and recommendations for remediation.

This step typically includes prioritizing vulnerabilities to ensure they are addressed effectively.

14. Regular updates and monitoring

Security is not a one-time effort.

Regular updates and continuous monitoring are essential to maintaining a secure posture against new and evolving threats.

Essential web security audit tools

Acunetix

Acunetix automatically creates a list of websites, applications, and APIs for scanning, ensuring comprehensive coverage. It can scan single page applications, script-heavy sites, and applications built with HTML5 and JavaScript, including areas that are password-protected or hard to reach.

Pros

Acunetix can detect over 7,000 vulnerabilities, including zero-days. It offers a blend of DAST + IAST scanning, minimizing false positives and pinpointing exact lines of code that need fixing. Integration into developers’ tools is also a key feature.

Cons

May not be suitable for very small businesses or individuals due to pricing.

Pricing

Based on long-term subscription agreements, varying by the number of websites or web applications scanned and the length of the contract

Burp Suite by PortSwigger

Burp Suite is a comprehensive tool for web application security testing, known for its extensive scanning and vulnerability detection capabilities.

Pros

Offers a wide range of features and is considered competitively priced. The Professional edition is ideal for individual users, while the Enterprise edition is suited for larger organizations.

Cons

Some users might find the interface complex, and the learning curve can be steep for beginners.

Pricing

Burp Suite Professional is priced at $449 per user per year. The Enterprise Edition costs $9,236 per year for five concurrent scans, with additional scans at $659 each per year.

ScanRepeat

ScanRepeat is a continuous security audit tool dedicated to SaaS and ecommerce web applications which doesn’t require any code changes.

Using ScanRepeat is very easy and fast, to scan your project you need to enter a URL address of your web application. Once you’ve set up your scan project, ScanRepeat will perform security scans for the specified URL, identifying vulnerabilities, compliance issues and other potential security problems in the web application.

This process helps to detect and address security vulnerabilities proactively, ensuring that your web applications are robust and secure.

Pros

ScanRepeat stands out for its user-friendly interface, flexible scan options for multiple projects, continuous security audit capabilities, and affordable pricing, all available without the requirement of a credit card.

Cons

As the tool is designed primarily for scanning web applications, it might not be as effective or suitable for other types of cybersecurity needs or IT infrastructures​​.

Pricing

Pricing ranges from $9.95 for individual plans to $19 per month for commercial applications. Includes 14-day free trial.

Nessus by Tenable

Nessus is a vulnerability scanner that offers comprehensive assessments of potential vulnerabilities in web applications.

Pros

Known for its thoroughness and accuracy in vulnerability detection.

Cons

The cost can be high for small businesses or individual users.

Pricing

A one-year subscription costs $3,590, with longer-term subscriptions available at a reduced rate per year. Additional support and training options are available for an extra fee.

Intruder

Intruder is a cloud-based vulnerability scanner that helps to find weaknesses in your online systems before the hackers do1. It works by performing infrastructure security audits, cloud security reviews, and web application assessments on your systems, using a range of scanning techniques and threat intelligence.

Source: Intruder

Pros

It allows you to target specific audience segments and customize your scans according to your needs and preferences.

Cons

It may not be able to detect some of the more advanced or obscure vulnerabilities that require manual testing or human intervention.

Conclusion

Keeping a website secure is a big deal. Audits help find problems before they become serious. They make sure the site is following the rules, keeping users’ information safe, and running smoothly. Regular website security audits performed with the right tools are key to keeping a website healthy in the digital world.

We are Stratoflow, a custom software development company. We firmly believe that software craftsmanship, collaboration and effective communication is key in delivering complex software projects. This allows us to build advanced high-performance Java applications capable of processing vast amounts of data in a short time. We also provide our clients with an option to outsource and hire Java developers to extend their teams with experienced professionals. As a result, our Java software development services contribute to our clients’ business growth. We specialize in travel software, ecommerce software, and fintech software development. In addition, we are taking low-code to a new level with our Open-Source Low-Code Platform.